 via faculty.mercer.edu/spears My buddy C and I enjoy exchanging stories about the funny, traumatic, or improbable "sir"-ings bestowed on us. We began talking about manners surrounding the incidents; what do we want people to do after they mistakenly refer to us with male pronouns, then realize their mistake? Here's our advice: Things to do after you make a mistake about someone's gender:
We'd love to end this post here, but unfortunately, personal experience suggests that a second list is warranted. Things NOT to do after you make a mistake about someone's gender:
28 Comments
mik goodramm
10/21/2012 09:58:25 am
I once got a lift home to my boat with a rlly heavy bag of concrete tHat I was going to have to take on the bus when I got sir'd now that's what I call an apology!
Donna
10/18/2012 09:45:47 am
Too funny. I've had all of the above happen except for #7.
JB
10/18/2012 01:07:44 pm
I think the funniest time for me was when I was in Las Vegas, in a casino going to restroom and just as I was walking in this woman was opening the door coming out, and literlly SCREAMED in my face!! LOL..i've been at fast food restaurants, movie theaters, regular restaurants..basically anywhere and had them look me in the eye and call me "Sir"..I also work on the phone, and I get it there too! Maybe I am really a Sir? LOL
debra burdis
11/3/2017 07:46:01 pm
It had happened all my lige
Ember
10/18/2012 01:11:26 pm
Great post and LOVE love love Tig!!
Kirby
10/18/2012 03:01:35 pm
Great list!
Zander
10/19/2012 02:43:32 am
I was recently in a coffee shop and a man was talking to his daughter and said "Honey move to let this..." He audibly paused and looked straight at me and then proceeded with "lady go by". It was priceless.
Ian
10/21/2012 06:02:40 am
I got the same thing when working in a retail shop years ago (pre transition)! A man and his young daughter got on the elevator with me. The little girl said, "Dad, where is the kid's section?", and dad says, "Let's ask this [turning to look at me] uh... this...", followed by total, mortified bafflement. He never finished his sentence, just embarrased-ly scuttled off of the elevator when we reached our floor. I still laugh every time I think of it!
Burnthejacket
10/21/2012 06:11:57 pm
He couldn't think to say "person"?
Susan
10/19/2012 03:13:27 am
I get sir'd constantly at my job. I'm a flight attendant with very short hair who happens to wear pants, shirt, and tie. I shrug it off because I realize the flying public isn't expecting a female flight attendant that looks like me.
katie
10/19/2012 03:46:52 am
I get the bathroom looks all the time, recently i was at a hotel and even though the guy was holding the driver license in his hand with my pic and info still called me Sir constantly. what gets me though, is that you never EVER see a man go into to the ladies room, but chicks always invade the men's bathroom. that is what bugs me Even when my hair is shorter than it is now, most people can figure out my gender -- they see a small person with breasts and make their assumptions. But once when I was leaving a restroom in what a woman assumed was an aggressive manner (I was leaving and didn't see her coming in, so I nearly bumped into her), she deliberately called me "Sir." I'm sure she'd also assumed I was a lesbian because I was wearing a lavender Provincetown sweatshirt. She was really nasty about it. I decided discretion was the better part of valor and didn't call her something unpleasant. What shocked me was that this was in an "art house" movie theater in overly-educated, multicultural Amherst, Mass. I guess ignorant homo-hating knows no bounds...
Heike
10/20/2012 03:36:46 am
Great points. I recently was staying at a small hotel in Germany and the first one to appear at breakfast. There was only one woman still preparing the buffet. She was in the kitchen when I came in and passing the door to the kitchen I said Good Morning to her and went thru to the porch as she was not all set up, yet. She came out and saw only me and still looking at me said - I heard a woman speak, where is she? - which I answered with - Here I am - she stared at me - her mouth dropped open - she slammed her hands in front of her face - screamed a loud OMG and run off. To me it was just funny and if she would have showed up again I would have told her that I am not bothered by the misunderstanding, but I guess she was to ashamed to come back and rather send her colleague to finish the breakfast preparations.
Cassandra
10/25/2012 09:08:40 am
I've gotten this all my life. For years I figured I wasn't acting girly enough and tried everything including growing my hair long. Never quite happened and this past weekend I actually had my hair cut short with a fade!lol Seeing as now I'm a Drag King I'm just more comfortable being who I really am. :) I'm loving the site. ;)
Carole
10/31/2012 07:22:30 am
This happens to me so often that I've ceased to be angry. Now it's just amusing and kind of sad. Sartorial cues help -- I've experimented and carrying a purse instead of a backpack definitely cuts down the gender mistakes by about 30%, and there are definitely a lot of situations where I'm more than willing to carry a purse just to proactively prevent incorrect assumptions. It does leave me kind of sad about the narrowness of people's perceptions that 70% of the mistakes still happen anyway.
KK
11/15/2012 06:02:44 am
This "mistake" has been a norm for me since I was 13 yrs old. Didn't matter if my hair was long or short. Didn't matter if I was having a good boob day. If I put on a dress, I'd look like I was in bad drag (no offense to anyone). Now I feel I need to explain that last comment a little. I'm 6'3", 280. Yes I'm a big 'un.
SusieQ
11/16/2012 06:17:00 pm
Once I had a garage attendant refuse my credit card as he thought I had picked up my wife's card by mistake !
AJ Murray
2/3/2013 09:36:14 am
I would prefer if people stopped using gendered titles in the first place, refer to us all as people or folks, and recognize that not everyone fits the gender binary. But I know when I travel to the US people do use titles more. So my advice would be - don't assume that it's an insult to be called a sir - just stop and carry on. Personally being called sir validates that I'm looking the way I want to look (masculine), so I kind of like it, I just don't like the way people falling all over themselves afterward to apologize, like the way they perceived me is such a terrible thing! I *do* know what I look like :)
AJ
2/3/2013 09:38:50 am
Can you delete my above comment or remove the sir name? Auto-complete put my name in when I didn't mean it to. Thanks
Jess
3/6/2013 05:00:09 pm
Hilarious examples from this year alone... I was recently asked "how does it feel to be an older brother?" while out with the children I nanny and their mother. I also got handed a pair of shoes and asked if I'd like to try them on first when I went shoe shopping with my mother, for my little brother, after she said she needed shoes for her son to match his high school uniform. So not only do I apparently appear male, but also juvenile. I'm 25. To those who say I should look more like a woman, I maintain that I do look like a woman. I am a woman, so clearly some women look like this. :) Love this blog.
nikosh
11/10/2014 03:20:22 pm
I am a cisgender (first time using this term hope I'm doing it right) hetero lady and I just stumbled on this page by googling "Mistook woman for a man what to do." I was recently at a formal dinner with some acquaintances and strangers and the table was full of women, except for my husband and (I thought) one other guy at the other end of the table. I loudly noted that both the guys at the table were outnumbered and flanked by so many ladies. Then after a few minutes, I realized that the guy at the other end was really a butch woman. I was embarrassed, and went over pretty soon afterward and apologized. I did complement her on her suit, she looked amazing and dapper - it was after all a formal dinner. She had a sweet tie clip! I now realize it was stupid of me to do that, but I felt awkward and wanted to express something positive after doing something stupid. I was ashamed for behaving in such a heteronormative or cisgender-privileged way, and I hope I didn't make it awkward by over-apologizing through my compliment. All this to share what this situation is like from someone who is figuring out how to show the respect that I have for the brave folks who are challenging the status quo, someone who now realizes how easy it can be to be unwittingly disrespectful or to make things awkward for others for whom society makes life more difficult. Thanks for this post! I will try to do my best to be supportive and less awkward in the future, and to check my hetero/cisgender privilege.
Christy
1/7/2016 10:53:07 pm
im a female, not butch, and get constantly called a man, anything i can say to those blind idiots?!?! im constantly called a tranny, crossdresser, shemale and mtf. like ive had 2 kids, the pics they used were 5 years old and i was 5 months pregnant in the main one they chose to call me a man.
Sam
9/18/2016 01:49:58 am
I'm 14 I recently had a volleyball tournament. We were in the first rounds of playoffs and I was serving the first point of our game. Right before he blew the whistle he hesitated and asked my coach to come to the middle of the court with him. The crowd was confused. The ref asked (loudly) "is THAT a NORMAL player?" Everyone watching, my team, the other team, people I know all saw that. My coach immediately saw what u was feeling on the inside and said to the ref "start the dam game." I immediately just wanted to be benched because that was emotionally too much for me. That's the fifth time a situation in questioning if I was trans or a boy. Later that night I cried myself to sleep. ( I have short blonde and brown hair, a little bit longer than Megan rapino) everyone on my team was staring at me ;( Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
|
RSS Feed
